Your Limbic Brain Conspires to Keep You from Making Good Decisions

According to accepted neuroscience, we have three brains: our brain stem, which controls motor function, our limbic or emotional brain and our neo cortex or rational thinking brain.

Our limbic, emotional brain, which is some 400 million years older than our neo cortex is primitive. Its purpose is to ensure survival, and all the complicated emotions and behaviors that survival implies. It is here that our basest of instincts thrive: sex, fury, fight. It is short term oriented, visual, concrete and self centered, and it is not designed to deal with abstract, complex concepts and ideas.

Ruled by the limbic brain, our ancestors were obsessed with consuming vital resources to keep them alive. They were consumption oriented not savings oriented. They were short term, immediate gratification oriented. They never thought about storing and saving because they never knew if they were going to survive from one day to the next. Consequently, they consumed not saved.

According to Robert Trivers, an evolutionary biologist at Rutgers University, “There isn’t necessarily a stop mechanism in us that says, Relax, you’ve got enough. We’ve evolved to be maximizing machines.”

For our ancestors the best way to save for the future was to consume now. Eating as much as they could, whenever they could, they were able to store extra calories in their bodies, in the hopes that this would carry them through any lean times that lay ahead.

This ancestrally dominated mindset has created many modern day problems: the tendency to spend and consume without any regard to the long term consequences, the addiction to instant gratification and the rejection of self denial and sacrifice, lack of patience and civility in society, micro term decision making by business and political leaders and on and on and on.

According to some Evolutionary Psychologists, our thinking, analytical, neo cortex brain has not evolved to keep pace with our complex, break neck speed society. Consequently, we are trying to cope in a complicated, frenetic world by using a brain that was designed to deal with much more basic human needs.

If our rational, analytical, thinking neo-cortex were truly in charge of our behavior we would engage in rational, intelligent, and civilized ways, but one does not have to look far to see the consequences of a society void of rational thought and dominated by the short term, emotionally motivated limbic brain.

Next time you make a decision, any decision, ask yourself is this a thoroughly planned, rationally thought out decision or am I making a decision based on short term, emotional gratification? If you are truly self aware and honest your answer will astound you.

4 replies
  1. Joe Biondo
    Joe Biondo says:

    Your article reeks with social concensus bias, and isn’t scientifically sound. When you equate the limbic system with a motivational system that can’t “sacrifice for the future” or is “selfish”, I can’t help but conclude that the authors are actually cheerleaders for a civilization that is run by a “selfish” species dominated by capitalism and religion. Unfortunately, this kind of “patriotic” reasoning is precisely why the neo-cortex is blindly intelligent, and only rationalizes in its’ attempt to promote a economic system that is now shown to be defunct. Nature, and the limbic system is far more “rational” because it specifically “fits into” the overall ecosystem, the only reliable model that we should exist in. Abstraction IS the problem on Planet Earth. Thanks

    Reply
    • Linda
      Linda says:

      I think all that is needed to see the truth of this article is to look at the state of our current world to see where our limbic (reptilian) brain has gotten us.

      Reply
  2. Michael K.
    Michael K. says:

    For all of Joe’s good intentions, his reaction exemplifies the basis of the article. He had to be “more OK” than the author. What’s wrong with just accepting the information and using it for evaluative purposes instead of reacting with such emotional bias. I argue that the article is not only scientifically sound, it’s exercised by those in the human race on a daily basis. Look around at the world conditions and this article is fully supported.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *